With all of the frenzy surrounding North Carolina’s
Amendment 1 and the president coming out (pardon the pun) in support of gay
marriage, I thought it was the right time for my “gay post.”
I never questioned the sinfulness of homosexual behavior. That
is what I was taught, that’s what I read and that’s what I “knew.” Having never
struggled with those feelings myself, it was easy for me to judge those who
did. After all, the Bible says it’s an abomination, right? And therefore
Christians should support governmental legislation to discourage this sin,
right?
Then a little over a year ago I was challenged by my best
friend. Most Christians are familiar with Jennifer Knapp, a contemporary
Christian musician who came out as a lesbian a few years ago. Lisa posted about
her story on Facebook. She later called me in tears about the response she’d
gotten. I have to admit, I judged Jennifer, too. As usual, Christians shoot their wounded. But
Lisa’s tears and stories about the horrid treatment of gay people by her church
moved me. I questioned what I “knew” for the first time.
I have dear friends and family members who are homosexual.
Them being gay never changed me loving them. But me loving them did not stop me
from sitting in judgment of their activity, and I felt justified. It’s in Leviticus,
after all. But so are lots of other things that we don’t blink at, such as
sexual activity during a woman’s menstrual cycle, eating shellfish, pork and
wearing clothes made of multiple materials. Even a woman not being a virgin
when she marries is grounds for capital punishment per Leviticus.
Is homosexuality a sin? Leviticus was NOT going to be enough
to convince me anymore. But then there’s the book of Romans. Yes, Romans definitely
appears to condemn gays. But I started to ask myself why. I know why many things
are sins. It’s obvious. Cheating, lying, stealing, murdering obviously hurt
fellow human beings and the perpetrator as well. But WHY would a loving AND
sexual relationship between two members of the same sex be sin when no one is
hurt?
Do I just need to shut up and quit asking questions? Or are
we misreading the Bible? Was it properly translated? Was the understanding of “homosexual”
the same in the days those books were written as it is today? Does Romans even
matter, since it technically is not “scripture” (aka Old Testament)as the early
Christians understood scripture and even if it was, we are no longer subject to
the law thanks to Jesus Christ.
I struggled. I struggle still. WHY is it a sin?
In my search for answers, I came upon the following video
given by a gay Christian at a church coincidentally in Wichita, where I used to
live. So far this is the best Biblical defense for homosexuality I have heard.
I do find holes in his arguments, but his passion and his struggle convicts me.
This young man wants to live for God…and still be true to himself. Do they have
to be mutually exclusive?
It is long, but I strongly, strongly encourage you to watch his speech no matter which side of the fence you are on. Jesus loves this kid, and it’s easy to see why.
So, is homosexuality a sin or not?
I was born painfully shy. It served as a debilitating character
trait for many years of my life. I have struggled to overcome it in order to
live a normal and successful life. I was born this way. Could I act not shy?
Yes! I can and I have. And doing so has helped me in various circumstances.
However, I cannot live that way. It IS an act. I am most happy spending time
with those that I know well, that I am comfortable around. Having to put on a
charade of “extrovertedness” 24/7 would kill me.
Is being shy a sin? I’d say it could be. If I was too
fearful to tell someone there’s a huge hole right in front of them and they
fall in and get hurt, yes, I’d say that was a sin. I utterly failed to love
that person enough to warn them. Is it a sin for me to want to stay home all
weekend with my husband and not speak to another living soul? Probably not.
So perhaps…just perhaps…homosexuality is the same thing. I
have no doubt people are born that way. It is not normal any more than my
shyness is normal. But if you take this trait and use it to harm yourself or
others, is it most definitely sin. If you use it in love (a committed
relationship, or my quiet devotion to my spouse all weekend) what will God hold
against you?
This is where I’m at. Only God can say for sure one way or
the other. Jesus never addressed homosexuality that we know of. It seems that
if it were that important he would have said something. But the gospels are silent. I would rather err on the
side of love. I will embrace and accept gay people as they are. If God wants to
change them he will. But that is not my job. My job is to love them. And they
are so worth loving.
This is where I’m at on my journey. We are all on our own journeys.
Maybe you are at a different place. I would love to hear where you are on this.
My position may evolve, but my love for these wonderful people who happen to be
gay or lesbian never well.